Harvard Law Classmates Call Out Gonzales

Back in April, embattled Attorney General Alberto Gonzales attended his 25th reunion at Harvard Law School. At that time, a group of current HLS students protested his attendance. This week, a group of fifty-six of his old Harvard Law classmates took out an ad in the Washington Post condemning Gonzales for his "failure to stand for the rule of law," among other complaints. They did not go so far as to call for the Attorney General's resignation, but rather call for him and the President to "relent from this reckless path." The purpose of the letter was not only to express their displeasure at the administration, but also to encourage others to feel comfortable enough to do the same.

One of the letter's authors, David Abromowitz of Boston, told me that this was not the typical group one might imagine taking out advocacy ads and openly criticizing the sitting Attorney General and President. Many of the signatories are currently working in large, corporate law firms or are very senior in business and financial institutions. Some were editors of the Harvard Law Review. Abromowitz also noted that while some classmates they approached declined to sign because they held public office or had some other conflict, none expressed support for the current administration's policies.

Wednesday's Harvard Crimson has the story as well.

You can see the letter as it appeared in the Washington Post here (PDF), or read the full text after the jump.

Dear Attorney General Gonzales:

Twenty-five years ago we, like you, graduated from Harvard Law School. While we arrived via many different paths and held many different views, we were united in our deep respect for the Constitution and the rights it guaranteed. As members of the post-Watergate generation who chose careers in law, we understood the strong connection between our liberties as Americans and the adherence of public officials to the law of the land. We knew that the choice to abide by the law was even more critical when public officials were tempted to take legal shortcuts. Nowhere were we taught that the ends justified the means, or that freedoms for which Americans had fought and died should be set aside when inconvenient or challenging. To the contrary: our most precious freedoms, we learned, need defending most in times of crisis.

So it has been with dismay that we have watched your cavalier handling of our freedoms time and again. When it has been important that legal boundaries hold unbridled government power in check, you have instead used pretextual rationales and strained readings to justify an ever-expanding executive authority. Witness your White House memos sweeping aside the Geneva Conventions to justify torture, endangering our own servicemen and women; witness your advice to the President effectively reading Habeas Corpus out of our constitutional protections; witness your support of presidential statements claiming inherent power to wiretap American citizens without warrants (and the Administration’s stepped-up wiretapping campaign, taking advantage of those statements, which continues on your watch to this day); and witness your dismissive explanation of the troubling firings of numerous U.S. Attorneys, and their replacement with others more "loyal" to the President's politics, as merely "an overblown personnel matter." In these and other actions, we see a pattern. As a recent editorial put it, your approach has come to symbolize "disdain for the separation of powers, civil liberties and the rule of law."

As lawyers, and as a matter of principle, we can no longer be silent about this Administration's consistent disdain for the liberties we hold dear. Your failure to stand for the rule of law, particularly when faced with a President who makes the aggrandized claim of being a unitary executive, takes this country down a dangerous path.

Your country and your President are in dire need of an attorney who will do the tough job of providing independent counsel, especially when the advice runs counter to political expediency. Now more than ever, our country needs a President, and an Attorney General, who remember the apt observation attributed to Benjamin Franklin: "Those who would give up essential Liberty to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." We call on you and the President to relent from this reckless path, and begin to restore respect for the rule of law we all learned to love many years ago.